Application for residential development at Brookfields. Application reference 19/00489/FUL

Tameside Council’s Speaker’s Panel (Planning Committee) this morning (18th November) considered the application for the construction of 21 houses on land off Mill Lane.

The application was REFUSED on the grounds of highway safety and loss of residential amenity to residents in the area. The Panel discussion included presentations from Cllr Taf Sharif and Mr David Jones, who opposed the application on behalf other Elected Members and objectors and a representative of the developers to advocate for the development.

The application included a revision which took access from Stamford Road for the construction period, a feature which has caused much concern to local people and discussion from the Panel members.

The applicant does have a right of appeal to the Secretary of State, if they so wish.

The Town Council objected to the proposal in its original form, raised concerns as well over the Ecological survey content and findings and has recently again objected to the revised application.

Frank Travis,

Chair, Mossley Town Council

Brookfields Development – Message from Town Council Chair (Town Councillor Frank Travis)

I am posting this as Chair and on behalf of Mossley Town Council to express thanks to all the members of our community who have copied me into their objections submitted to Tameside MBC about the proposed development at Brookfields.

There can be no doubt about the powerful sentiments expressed by residents in their opposition to the proposal.

I hope you will understand that the Town Council is consulted on planning applications but the decision on those application will be made by Tameside MBC as Local Planning Authority.

The Town Council fully understands the concerns of local residents and supports them in their opposition to the development.

The Town Council has lodged a robust objection not only to the current revision to the application involving a temporary access from Stamford Street but also to the original application for the residential development.

In between lodging those objections, the Town Council has drawn Tameside MBC’s attention to failings in the ecological survey of the development site carried out by the developer and has again emphasised this to Tameside.

The Town Council is aware that other issues have now come to light which do not relate purely to planning considerations and local residents have and continue to voice concerns over these aspects. Whilst the Town Council understands the additional concerns, it is hoped that residents will acknowledge that the Town Council has no authority to influence these issues.

The Town Council will continue to support local residents wherever the powers and duties permit.

I hope that the Town Council’s position is now clear.

Frank Travis,

Chair, Mossley Town Council

 

Objection to the Proposed Development at Brookfields

The Town Council has lodged a robust objection to the planning application for proposed residential development comprising 21 family homes and associated works – amended plan to create temporary construction access from Stamford Road.

the wording of the objection is set out below:

“Mossley Town Council considered the amended plans to create a temporary construction access from Stamford Road at the Town Council meeting on 21 October 2020.

At the meeting, local residents voiced strong concerns about the original application and about the revised access proposal.

After carefully considering the case put forward by residents to the revision, the Town Council objects on the following grounds:

– The construction of an additional access onto Stamford Road even on a temporary basis will result in serious traffic problems on an extremely busy road resulting in additional danger to both pedestrians and other road users;

– The proposed access is inadequate for the types of construction vehicles visiting the site and is likely to result in construction vehicles parking on Stamford Road awaiting access or even unloading from Stamford Road and adding to traffic danger with vehicles accelerating downhill on Stamford Road having to give-way;

– The temporary access will involve the demolition of an existing historic dry-stone wall which is an important part of the street scene and even if rebuilt at the end of the temporary period, there will have a detrimental effect on the visual amenity of the locality;

Whilst focussing on the proposed amendment, residents voiced additional concerns about the main application which the Town Council fully supports. These include:

– A strong objection from the Milton St John’s Primary School in view of the close proximity to the school;

– The proposed development will result in an overdevelopment of the site;

– Recent issues involving heavy vehicles in the locality becoming stranded highlight the traffic issues and unsuitability of roads in the area for development of this type.

In summary, the Town Council considered the original planning application on 4 September 2019 and strongly opposed the development on the following grounds:

(1) the access to the proposed development via Mill Lane and Archer St is inappropriate, in particular due to its narrow width and close proximity to the nearby Milton St John’s School; and

(2) the proposed development will have a detrimental effect on the rich amount of wildlife in the immediate locality which contributes to the wellbeing and amenity of the local community.

The Town Council subsequently, on 26 February 2020 considered issues raised by members of the Town Council about the ecological survey of the site which had been conducted by Dunelm Ecology, Environmental Consultants on behalf of the applicant and commented as follows:

– The descriptions about existing trees on the site were unrealistic;

– The comments about wildlife on the site were inadequate, making reference to parts of the site being inaccessible to survey. These are likely to be the very areas inhabited by wildlife; and

– Overall, the ecological aspects of the site had been largely overlooked in the report.

In addition it was noted by the Council that the recent appeal for residential development on land nearby at Greaves Street has been dismissed.

The decision to dismiss this appeal makes particular mention of the lack of open space and makes the point that though that site had no status as open space, it made an important contribution to that local amenity factor. The Town Council submits that this space at Brookfields should be treated in the same manner and although there is a small park on Carrhill Rd, that is a formal space and this offers a complementary and valuable amenity not only for local people, but as a wildlife habitat.

The site at Brookfields is also cut off from the wider space amenity by Stockport Road and Manchester Road. The Inspector in the appeal case also referred to the public opinion on its value and use over many years. The public opinion here has been expressed extensively through social media.

The Town Council reaffirms the original objections to the development and urges Tameside MBC to closely examine the submitted ecological survey to adequately assess whether it accurately reflects the ecological environment of the site. The Town Council would like confirmation that Tameside MBC has assessed the accuracy of the ecological statement before proceeding to determine the application.

I should be glad if you would ensure that the Town Council’s objections are carefully considered prior to the applications being determined.”